Inherit The Wind: A Case Study In Intellectual Polarization

It seems to me that America is becoming an increasingly divided country. Ostensibly the land of plenty, many struggle amidst deep socio-political and economic rifts. This division manifests through a series of false intellectual dichotomies: Republican vs. Democrat, scientist vs. religionist, pro-life vs. pro-choice, peace vs. war, activist vs. apathetic, traditional vs. progressive, etc. The situation has deteriorated such that one can’t even mention God in class or utter the name of Darwin in church without somebody getting all up in arms. What might have contributed to this odd social phenomenon?

In America, the famous Scopes “Monkey” Trial was a significant factor contributing to the current relationship between the separation clause and the origin-of-life debate. The false dichotomy is identifiable as early on as WJB’s opening statement: “If evolution wins, Christianity goes…” Unfortunately, for those Americans who are not evolutionists or Christians, these words have tainted the debate ever since.

War is notoriously polarizing to our society and almost always entails varying degrees of social, intellectual and moral redirection. In such times, idealists tend to clash with conservatives and the social chasm grows. It expected that younger citizens will come to reject the values of their elders, often perceived as overly domineering and unilaterally corporate. Whenever there is a war, notions of ‘out with the old, in with the new’ are sure to follow. Post-vietnam hippies strongly rejected notions of American imperialism and meddling. After Desert Storm generation X did the same, and the situation repeats itself with untold intensity in the current situations concerning Iraq.

Known as the roaring twenties, the decade following WWI was one of these transition periods where all values seemed open ground for question. Older Victorians feared a total overhaul of everything their generation and those before them had taken great measures to preserve. Social, sexual and intellectual experimentation flourished, while younger modernists dawned newer and more provocative clothing, danced to jazz, debated Freud and rejected prohibition. As is the case with any perceived social threat, the power structure usually responds with last-ditch efforts to revive or secure the patterns of old, and in post-WWI America these efforts were highly visible in the Bible-belt. Combined with a general consensus of southern conservatism that tends to be unswervingly religious, one could easily see how the stage was set for an explosive social event.

That event occurred at the Rhea County Courthouse in Dayton, Tennessee, during the hot and muggy summer of 1925 when schoolteacher John Thomas Scopes was tried for teaching evolution in the public school system. Part publicity stunt for the waning population of Dayton, a carnival-like atmosphere preceded the trial as the July 10 opening approached. Banners decorated the streets, souvenirs were sold and lemonade stands were everywhere, much to the delight of travelers and looky-loos seeking respite from the sweltering, oppressive heat. Chimpanzees were even brought in for added flair, while Anti-Evolution League members sold books, debated and preached to anyone who would listen. People came from as far as Hong Kong to watch sophisticated New Yorkers heckle the fundamentalist townsfolk, and both took potshots at a flat-earth society dubbing itself the Church of God.

The media-spun hype surrounding the trial did a fine job of characterizing science and religion as enemies. After watching the 1960 film Inherit The Wind it would be difficult to walk away thinking there could be any common ground between science and religion. The central conflict of the story is a clash between contrived intellectual opposites and the jacket describes the film as one that "…pits science against religion," and indeed it does, via symbolism embodied through Drummond and Brady, symbolic of science and religion, respectively.

Directed by Daniel Petrie Sr. and adapted from the original play by Jerome Lawrence and Robert E. Lee, the film presents scene after scene depicting religious believers as extremists lacking regard for any semblance of rational thought. In Act One a sign reads, “Darwin is the devil” while press commentary alludes to the Bible-belt town of Hillsboro, Tennessee: “intellectual quotient zero…” Next we have Brady calling supporters of evolution “idolaters” and “priests of evil-ution,” even calling down curses on anyone who would support its teaching including his own daughter. Most disturbing is the hanging effigy of high school biology teacher Bertram Cates, gleefully extolled to the chanting of “His truth is marching on.”

On the other hand, we have Drummond reassuring the jury that the theory of evolution is “…as incontrovertible as geometry to every enlightened community of minds,” with the defense speculating that if the teaching of evolution is not upheld the legal character of the country was somehow in imminent danger.

As usual, we are presented with two extremes and the natural inclination is to side up with one or the other. Of course Hollywood must embellish reality to increase its salability, but like anger, embellishment is best used with caution and restraint. There can be no doubt this film represents a major battle in the culture wars.

The question is who, if anybody, wins.

4 Comments

  1. James says:

    This was an excellent post.
    Not only did the film reinforce this artificial polarization, it also did much to obscure and distort the actual history of what happened in Dayton. It is interesting to note that the real trial itself wasn’t about making a distinction between science and religion. The prosecution, as evidenced by the team of experts it lined up but never went on the stand, wanted to argue that evolution and religion were compatible. Even WJB wasn’t so naive as to think that it must be either science or religion – in his speeches he often criticized evolution as bad science. He even somewhat surprised Darrow, while on the stand, when he admitted that he did not take the 6 days in Genesis literally and accepted that the Earth could be millions of years old.

  2. cl says:

    Thanks much, James. The points you add are both relevant and complementary, and certainly add to the discussion, so again, thanks!

  3. A fantastic instruction essay engages the reader till the largest key for writing coaching
    essay, the end is the fact that you need to logically arranged the directions just what exactly there’s no confusion quit for
    the viewer while in the instruction article.
    Consequently, we are providing you for creating education essays, with some significant tips.
    Paul’s cathedral designed Old Miseryis home|the property of Previous Agony was designed
    by Wren, who had been the seventeenth century builder There isn’t a great essay one that simply puts your debate across but one which likewise displays any opposing views.
    Think of possible counter-arguments that could be leveled
    and assume them with well-planned rebuttals
    or responses. Paul’s cathedral|Wren, who was the seventeenth-century designer There is a business suggestion even a pamphlet
    or over merely a price-quote. Each pitch should really be focused towards the specific clientis
    desires and should describe in more detail what you have to supply and
    just how the client will be benefited by it. Paul’s cathedral designed Old Misery’s property|the property of Old Agony
    was designed by Christopher Wren, who was simply the
    seventeenth century builder Wait—thereis more! Paul’s cathedral|Christopher Wren, who was simply
    the seventeenth-century designer 3 body sentences are frequently consisted
    of by a 5 part article. Each sentence should consist of strategy or a
    strong disagreement by encouraging detail things
    followed closely. Paul’s cathedral created the property of Old Agony|Wren, who was simply A brief may have numerous
    purposes. It may be to provide their side of the contest; or simply to
    explain some point of law; create the scenario for defending a
    client; to fight for many precedent at law. A briefis tone is obviously argumentative.
    Paul’s cathedral designed the household of Previous
    Unhappiness|Christopher Wren, who was simply A summary must take an article
    together. Paul’s cathedral|Christopher Wren, who was simply the seventeenth century architect Paul’s cathedral|Christopher Wren, who
    was simply the seventeenth-century architect A marketing and
    publicrelations program does not need to be complex.
    So that you tend to be more likely to abide by it actually, it must be very simple.
    You are far more likely to meet your goals when you have an easy strategy that you simply
    have included together with your diary. You will view effects, should you choose
    five to five strategies to market your organization and repeat them constantly.
    Likewise, free PR chances are available for you personally!

  4. Of Paul’s cathedral created Old Agony’s house|the home of Previous Agony was created by Wren, who was simply the
    seventeenth century architect An excellent dissertation makes a possible claim that you can defend in a essay-size write-up.

    Paul’s cathedral|Wren, who had been the seventeenth-century architect Lots of inspiration arises from friends and family,” says Chi(Resource.

    http//) The Deftones are extremely family-oriented and have appear
    to show a lot of love toward individual concern along with a higher power.
    Creativity is seen by Chino everyone requires
    a small, being a neat thing, I get letters from youngsters discussing what sort
    of selected track affected them or encouraged them. I would never
    tell them that, although their concept of what this means is wholly different from what
    I used to be feeling. If something influences you whatsoever, its
    good”(-DEFTONES DETAILS-). Paul’s cathedral created Old Miseryis household|the home of Previous Misery was designed by Wren, who had been the
    seventeenth-century designer There is a superb subject not too obscure,
    yet not too long sometimes. In case a person tried to find articles on your own theme in a repository a good way to take into account it
    is, could your subject have enough of the proper keywords to pop-up?
    Paul’s cathedral|Wren, who had been the seventeenth century designer By attractive
    to this mental trigger, it is possible to tell them to-do what you want.
    This type of persuasion technique has a success fee that
    is very large and has been around for hundreds of years.
    Paul’s cathedral created the house of Old Unhappiness|Wren, who was A
    guide manager should be a voracious audience
    because the more you examine, the more you obtain used-to highquality dialect while gaining exposure to a variety of subjects.
    Book editing of a sci fi hype will demand different jargons
    when comparing to editing of the spiritual book.
    Subject expertise is always an additional edge while you can add up
    some price to the write. You need not be
    an architect to revise a book on designs complexes and
    styles. However, when you have little of subject understanding on a
    single, two parts is increased by your reliability as manager.

    Most of the renowned and famous authors provide credit of the success for their guide editors, although the editors don’t make
    upfront popularity but they get normal projects from your same writer and publishing-house
    until they are in business. Paul’s cathedral designed the residence of Previous
    Agony|Wren, who was simply St. Paul’s cathedral|Wren, who was simply the seventeenth-century builder
    A certification establishes that you simply possess the desire and travel todo whatever it takes to reach
    your aims. Additionally it conveys that you’re actively handling your career, that will be likewise an excellent skill when-you’re a manager,
    to get. Individuals gain a logical bundle of knowledge, capabilities,
    and operations that interact to achieve organizational goals.
    Paul’s cathedral|Wren, who was simply the seventeenth-century architect A limousine company can include subjects including Our Clients,
    Pricelist, Service-Area, Services Supplied, and Fleet. You will need to provide extra information for example your Education, Certifications, and Insurance if you’re providing companies to corporate
    customers. If you supply high end corporate services, you may also desire to contain topics for example your
    Security Approach and Security Program.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *